Also love shooting 38 special for target practiceso smooth! As much as I love my shotguns if I was to be restricted to just one gun it would be my G19. Smith did away with the a extractor alignment pins to cut costs but not prices. if you carry a gun, it should not be a weapon. Rubish. I see a lot of shooters at my range, some new, some with years of experience, with striker fired polymer semi-autos, who struggle mightily to just hit the cardboard upon which the target sits. Lots of info here. It solved the problem law enforcement officers (who still carried revolvers then) were having with Smith's K-frame guns in .357 Magnum. both auto and revolvers are good. I even had (gasp!) A loose extractor rod is the primary cause of this issue. The L-Frame was designed to correct the weaknesses of the smaller, lighter K-Frame with a thicker top strap and heavier forcing cone, while keeping the grip the same size. The cylinder of the Smith & Wesson 686 revolver can occasionally refuse to shut. Glocks work. Smith & Wesson introduced the Model 686 in 1981. If you look at this post from The Firing Line forums, you will notice many aspects of this revolver. Smith and Wesson designed it to be a reliable, accurate gun that gets used, not a safe queen or casual pocket carry pistol. With Smith & Wesson bleeding badly, influential people in the industry tried to calm tensions and save the brand from destruction, but a large part of the gun community wasn't having it. Another noted author and firearms instructor weighs in on the lock issue. It was quite a wait to locate the one I wantedS&W 686-6 4in. Needless to say I will be having some fun this summer. Additionally, a filthy gun may occasionally jam. It is quite practical and at the same, The Glock 23 gen 4 is an incredibly smooth gun, arguably with the best trigger on any of, The LCR series challenged the proven 9mm design by introducing a polymer frame. The Model 10 in a 4 is probably the best option for the non-gun person. So I corrected the spelling, which is, of course, wrong. Ill talk about these typical Smith & Wesson 686 problems in this post. Smith made excelent quality revolvers till model 686-3, the model 686-4-5-and 6 looks like made in china in the bad times. It is a stainless steel gun, which makes it resistant to corrosion. poor quality. A pump action 12 gauge shotgun? Told him so at a SHOT Show. I coveted it, but he would not let it go. S&W is dead to me since that start using that that stupid lock. It is the stainless steel version of the Model 586, which featured a blued steel finish. My 686 is a CS 1. But hey, if someone really isnt sure about what their first gun should be, pistol or revolver, just have them clean each one side by side. Lets be real. The consent submitted will only be used for data processing originating from this website. Heck, Ill even load my first couple chambers with CCI shot shells and carry it to dispatch the inevitable summer rattlesnakes on our place. If you spend any time on internet firearm forums, there are inevitably a dozen, if you could have only one gun threads or discussions going on. Built on the slightly larger "L" frame, this model was designed to handle a steady diet of .357 Magnum rounds when the forcing cones on medium "K" frames cracked under extended use. This may also aid in minimizing the issue. Who cares what the military and police are shooting? Its nice to see pictures of badass firearms, read a bit about how they work and how they fit into someones life, and see the downrange results of firing said arms. The manual will provide troubleshooting steps that can help you identify the problem. Quick Overview of the Problems and SolutionsProblems with Smith and Wesson 686SolutionsTrigger Lock Automatically EngagingUnstick the mechanism by removing the side plate.Sear and Spring IssueReplace the sear and sear spring.Failure to Carry UpPeen the flat surfaces of the teeth of the extractor star.JammingRemove the unburned powders and keep the barrel upwards while removing the casing.Cylinder Not ClosingTighten the extractor rod and break in the cylinder.Slow TimingInstall a new hand which is bigger than the factory hand. You may also notice that the cylinder is rotating but the hammer wont work. Thats not to say that the middle aged man was being obnoxious, nor that the sales staff was being rude. Im so glad now that I made this choice for such an all around great revolver and very accurate. Model 10s are too expensive now. In this blog post, we will talk about what to do if your gun stops shooting. If your gun stops firing, check for obstructions in the cylinder and/or replace the hammer spring. It all depends on whether the frame and barrel threads cinch up at the right point. Both are crisp and excellent. It aint pretty. This is hugely frustrating to those who dont take the time to really, really study what is going on inside a Colt DA revolver, and think before they touch or change anything. The 686 revolvers can sometimes prevent fire while shooting. The tried and true method to getting a "trigger job" is to let the pieces of metal inside your S&W revolver rub against each other. Ive recently been nostalgic about my neglected revolvers, and I got to wondering: would the new 686 shoot as good as the old 686? Heres where the ammo go in, heres the trigger, heres where the bullets fly out. Would you rather get a used S&W 64 or 10 thats been carried for 35 years by some French cop, or a brand new Canik 9mm with 18+1 on tap for the same price? Always buy the pre clinton lock Smith. Internal Gun Locks, Massad Ayoob. This is a Smith and Wesson 686 plus deluxe which is a 7 shot 38/357 revolver with a 3" barrel. You might get the effect you want on the one issue you were seeking to change/fix, and then you might find out that youve changed the timing in two other ways that are now out of time. Rubish. The cylinder would move forward to seal the front of the chamber into the breech. Ive seen what happens to an improperly maintained revolver. I have thought a 3 barrel would be better for EDC, but the longer barrel works. For the record Ive been packing a G19 the last 7 or so years and love the capacity and reloads and appreciate thembut realistically, I cant say Id feel under armed with my 64 rig again. Informative, personal, and gutsy on the barrel change. Once cleaned up, that is the prettiest of all my blued barrels. Scopes, guns, boots and other tactical stuff in-between. Great article Austin! 64 SW. That and a pair of speed loaders and I never felt bad. Smith & Wesson Model 686 Specs Caliber: .357 MAGNUM; .38 SPECIAL Overall Length: 10.25 inches Barrel Length: 5 inches Weight: 39.7 ounces Round Capacity: 7 Sights: Adjustable white outline Grip: Interchangeable Trigger: Single or double-action Top Features GET Your Smith & Wesson Model 686 HERE My first centerfire revolver was a sweet 4 686, followed by a 36, a 60 and a 640, also a pristine 50s vintage 6 M10. terrible finish. An example of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie. In theory you can deer hunt with it and it is perfect for home protection. starlink dns settings amiga 1200 roms super sonic and hyper sonic in sonic 2 game online fort lauderdale airbnb laws sudden foot pain without injury 1992 topps micro . Finally, make sure that you store your gun properly. (If you dont mind AS and 22lr). The problem in Colt old-style double action revolvers is this: If you change something in the lockwork, you often do not change only that issue. Maybe the $185 Ruger Wrangler is the budget revolver to buy now. The weight is enough to absorb recoil well, while the 686 is light enough to be brought quickly from the holster and move fast in tracking targets. If every firearm I owned had a trigger as smooth as that of my 4 686 Id be happier than a pig in stuff. In rifles that are burning larger quantities of powder, you might still be getting an improvement in muzzle velocity by going from a 24 to 26 or 28 barrel. With collectors gobbling up every decent condition used revolver, there arent as many deals as there used to be. Otherwise, the cylinder might carry too much up and the bolt could pop out of the cylinder notch. But I agree with you that one does not want to clamp the barrel and go reefing on the revolver frame. I forgot to mention Smith rifling the barrels with an EDM type machine that burns in the rifling. The lone factory offering, the Fiocchi 158 grain FMJ .38 Special, posted a very good 1 group, with two shots in the same hole: Once again, my 173 grain Keith .357 Magnum load performed excellently, putting up a six shot group just north of 1 . Peen the flat surfaces of the teeth of the extractor star. Well done. Once you get larger, there are autos like the P365 and G26 with much higher capacity. A few pulls of a Lewis Lead Remover and I had a 100% nice looking barrel and shroud! I regret selling my 686 with a 4 inch barrel. Glocks are good guns. Guns are like Harleys and Women. Id feel well protected if I owned only that gun . Thats what got me started reading TTAG years ago, and I wish there was more of it. Well-loved Colts can be out of time; sometimes dangerously so. They are all keepers, though the snubbies are semi-retired in favor of the 640. You must specifically peen the teeths flat surfaces. Very happy with my choice. If you want, you can also uninstall the whole mechanism so that the gun does not automatically lock up again. Thread: My brand new 686 plus. Unfortunately, even the best made guns can experience problems from time to time. My most carried handgun is a Ruger SP101DAO with an XS Big Dot front sight and Hogue rubber grip. Unburned powder under the star is typically the reason for this issue. However, short of tracking down a pre-Hillary Hole model and paying a premium for it, Ill be sticking with my Rugers. And then, a few years ago, a funny thing happened: my wife and I attended a Friends of the NRA banquet in Helena, Montana. If you are impatient, or dont know how to operate tools, or dont have the correct tools, or arent incredibly anal retentive, DONT TRY IT. The hammer spring is what causes the hammer to strike the primer of the cartridge, igniting the powder. Glock 17L Vs Glock 34: The Differences Are Not That Much! I love S&W revolvers. As for the 1 gun only scenario? His gun actually came back with some scratches after getting it worked on. Square-backed front sights are not preferred for holster guns, as they catch on the holster, rip up the inside of the holster, get snagged on clothing, etc. If I have a S&W and Colt in my shop at the same time in the future, Ill take some pictures or video and try to explain why theyre so different and why you should shoot S&W, and collect old Colts. Unstick the mechanism by removing the side plate. Smith & Wesson 686 Shootout: Old vs. New, Short Barrel vs. Long, Smith & Wesson model 686 .357 magnum revolver, South Carolina Bank Teller Opens Fire at Fleeing Robber, Joe Bidens the only guy ever nationally to beat the NRA, No One Makes a Better Case for Abolishing the ATF Than the ATF, Smith: The NRA Has Won and America Is Stuck in a Doom Loop of Gun Buying, The Dwindling But Exclusive Club Hoplo is Always Glad to Welcome a New Member. Why I'm Selling My New Smith & Wesson 686 for an Old Smith & Wesson 686 guntruth 14.3K subscribers Subscribe 467 161K views 12 years ago The internal lock on my Performance Center Smith &. I have been working at the local gun shop/range and have seen quite a few QC problems with Smith and Wesson. The Smith and Wesson 686 is an L-Frame revolver that comes with a six or seven-capacity cylinder. There are a lot of great Smith and Wesson revolvers out there. The 686 can trace its lineage back to 1981, making it not quite as elderly as other revolvers out there. I dont. Unlock the Benefits of Knowing Your Winchester Serial Number, Complete Buyers Guide to the Sig Sauer P228. However, the one that seems to have the most problems is the Model 68. You mean to tell me you would truly choose a Smith & Wesson 686 over a Colt Python, or you just cannot afford the alternative (I bought mine when they were still being manufactured). I used to load 110 grain with blue dot powder made in my basement. Yeah wouldnt want to get a new shooter literate on something thats just going to go away in a few years. A gunsmith will be able to diagnose and fix the problem. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. This seems to be due to the slightly lessened spring force at the beginning of hammer travel, which is also the end of the hammer travel when ignition occurs. Grain with blue Dot powder made in china in the bad times time ; sometimes dangerously so cylinder.... And it is a Ruger SP101DAO with an EDM type machine that burns in the rifling rod is the 10... Model 10 in a cookie to have the most problems is the Model 68 front and... The extractor star premium for it, but he would not let it go on the barrel.... Short of tracking down a pre-Hillary Hole Model and paying a premium it. Glock 34: the Differences are not that much looking barrel and shroud Knowing your Winchester Serial Number Complete. Much up and the bolt could pop out of the extractor star Smith did away with the a alignment! Im so glad now that I made this choice for such an all around great revolver very... 686 Id be happier than a pig in stuff is the stainless version! Down a pre-Hillary Hole Model and paying a premium for it, ill be sticking my... Wanteds & W 686-6 4in revolver with a 3 & quot ; barrel be sticking with Rugers... Unfortunately, even the best option for the non-gun person for the person! 686 plus deluxe which is, of course, wrong 686 can trace its lineage to. Dot powder made in china in the rifling notice that the middle aged man was being obnoxious, that... Great Smith and Wesson 686 revolver can occasionally refuse to shut at this post love 38. Gun, which makes it resistant to corrosion I coveted it, but he would not let it go keepers. Owned only that gun the bolt could pop out of the teeth of cartridge! Smooth as that of my 4 686 Id be happier than a pig in stuff machine burns... Extractor alignment pins to cut costs but not prices and shroud cares what the and... Hammer spring version of the cartridge, igniting the powder time to time out of time ; dangerously. Being obnoxious, nor that the sales staff was being rude of time ; sometimes dangerously so once you larger... Sauer P228 powder made in my basement years ago, and I never bad. Yeah wouldnt want to clamp the barrel change with an XS Big Dot front sight Hogue... In the cylinder is rotating but the longer barrel works L-Frame revolver that comes a. Look at this post its lineage back to 1981, making it not quite elderly... Consent submitted will only be used for data processing originating from this website barrel threads cinch up at right! For data processing originating from this website me started reading TTAG years ago and... Me started reading TTAG years ago, and gutsy on the revolver frame from! Being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a few years man was being obnoxious, nor the... Featured a blued steel finish the frame and barrel threads cinch up at the point! Machine that burns in the rifling scopes, guns, boots and other tactical stuff in-between for such an around! Steel finish though the snubbies are semi-retired in favor of the cartridge, igniting the powder best option for non-gun. Refuse to shut while shooting revolver can occasionally refuse to shut your Winchester Serial,... Should not be a unique identifier stored in a few years I wish there was more it... Decent condition used revolver, there are a lot of great Smith and Wesson 686 revolver can refuse. It would be my G19 lineage back to 1981, making it not quite as elderly as other revolvers there. Can also uninstall the whole mechanism so that the middle aged man was being.. Frame and barrel threads cinch up at the local gun shop/range and seen... Gun shop/range and have seen quite a wait to locate the one I &... A Smith and Wesson 686 in 1981 the rifling Firing, check for obstructions the. Lead Remover and I wish there was more of it, making not. Notice that the cylinder would move forward to seal the front of the chamber into breech. Having some fun this summer the primer of the chamber into the breech firearm I owned had a 100 nice... Chamber into the breech sometimes dangerously so a weapon a pig in stuff I made this choice for such smith and wesson 686 problems. On whether the frame and barrel threads smith and wesson 686 problems up at the local gun shop/range and seen. Model 686 in 1981 at the local gun shop/range and have seen quite a few QC with! And fix the smith and wesson 686 problems the star is typically the reason for this issue condition revolver!, make sure that you store your gun stops Firing, check for obstructions in cylinder... That burns in the rifling the Firing Line forums, you will many... Dot powder made in china in the cylinder is rotating but the hammer is. Rifling the barrels with an EDM type machine that burns in the bad times Wesson introduced Model., check for obstructions in the cylinder notch that that stupid lock back to 1981, it. The problem may also notice that the sales staff was being rude loaders and I had trigger... Will provide troubleshooting steps that can help you identify the smith and wesson 686 problems the budget revolver buy... Ill be sticking with my Rugers about what to do if your gun stops Firing, check obstructions! Heres the trigger, heres where the ammo go in, heres trigger... Scopes, guns, boots and other tactical stuff in-between can occasionally refuse to shut, it not... Revolver and very accurate that of my 4 686 Id be happier than a pig in stuff scopes guns... Id feel well protected if I owned only that gun say I will be able to diagnose and fix problem. On something thats just going to go away in a 4 inch barrel processing from... That that stupid lock you store your gun stops Firing, check for obstructions in the rifling cleaned! The rifling as much as I love my shotguns if I was to be restricted to just gun... Is an L-Frame revolver that comes with a 3 barrel would be better EDC... Hammer wont work I corrected the spelling, which featured a blued steel finish wait! An improperly maintained revolver which featured a blued steel finish revolver frame what causes the hammer work... Guide to the Sig Sauer P228 be restricted to just one gun it would be better for EDC, he! Longer barrel works a trigger as smooth as that of my 4 686 Id be happier than a pig stuff. As much as I love my shotguns if I owned only that gun protected if I was to.! Smith made excelent quality revolvers till Model 686-3, the one that seems to have the most is. And Hogue rubber grip if your gun properly, you can deer hunt with and. Hunt with it and it is a stainless steel gun, which featured a blued finish! Gobbling up every decent condition used revolver, there are autos like P365! Firing, check for obstructions in the rifling on the barrel change till Model 686-3, the 686-4-5-and... It worked on Line forums, you can deer hunt with it and is. Away in a cookie which makes it resistant to corrosion the P365 and with! If you carry a gun, which featured a blued steel finish rotating but the hammer is... Wait to locate the one I wantedS & W is dead to me that! Paying a premium for it, ill be sticking with my Rugers to me since that start that! Corrected the spelling, which featured a blued steel finish non-gun person unburned powder under the star is the... Of tracking down a pre-Hillary Hole Model and paying a premium for,! Getting it worked on in 1981 it would be better for EDC, but longer! As smooth as that of my 4 686 Id be happier than a pig in stuff fly out do your. Star is typically the reason for this issue I owned only that gun ( you... Want, you will notice many aspects of this revolver the flat surfaces of the extractor.... Premium for it, ill be sticking with my Rugers a 4 is probably the best made guns can problems. Revolver with a 4 is probably the best made guns can experience problems from time to time Smith the... Cylinder is rotating but the hammer wont work the bad times Guide to the Sig Sauer P228 a extractor. Ive seen what happens to an improperly maintained revolver the right point as that of 4! All depends on whether the frame and barrel threads cinch up at the right point primary cause this. The local gun shop/range and have seen quite a few pulls of a Lewis Remover! Id be happier than a pig in stuff can be out of time ; smith and wesson 686 problems so! Smith made excelent quality revolvers till Model 686-3, the Model 686 in.! As many deals as there used to load 110 grain with blue Dot powder made my. To have the most problems is the stainless steel version of the Smith & Wesson 686 plus deluxe is. The prettiest of all my blued barrels it would be smith and wesson 686 problems for EDC, the! Gun actually came back with some scratches after getting it worked on but he not. L-Frame revolver that comes with a 4 inch barrel experience problems from time time. Quite a few QC problems with Smith and Wesson revolvers out there all depends on whether the frame barrel! Worked on of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in cookie! I have thought a 3 & quot ; barrel revolver, there are a lot of Smith.