When a Dahlia enthusiast heard about Harnischs investigation, he sent him a box filled with photocopies of newspaper articles about the crime, a transcript of the inquest that contained most of the autopsy notes, a homemade documentary, a copy of Shorts grades from elementary school, and a dim photocopy of the marriage certificate of her oldest sister, Virginia Short. At about 10 a.m., she was pushing her three-year-old daughter in a strollernot just any stroller, but a Taylor-Tot stroller, she was proud to point outto a repair shop to pick up her husbands shoes. While other Los Angeles murder victims had been brutalized and their bodies mutilated, Harnisch acknowledges there was something sui generis about what the killer had done to Elizabeth Short. The living room in his 1910 bungalow is cluttered with his great-grandmothers china cabinet and mirrors; his grandfathers tool chest, which he uses as a coffee table; his mothers piano; a Maxfield Parish lithograph that his grandfather gave his grandmother when they married; and on the mantle his grandparents candelabras and an antique German wind-up clock. As a result, he was committed to Patton State Hospital by his wife in 1954. Bayleys lesion and drastic personality change could be the result of, Frontotemporal dementia from a series of little strokes, Fallon says. Still, Shorts mother refused to believe her daughter was dead. The homes are well kept, the lawns trimmed, and the shrubbery pruned. In five other books Hodel describes his investigation into these killings. In addition to Short, Hodel claimed in the book that his father also killed Jeanne French a month later, which was called by the newspapers the Red Lipstick Murder because of the writing on the body. She was the matron of honor at the wedding of Elizabeth Shorts oldest sister in Inglewood. He also identified Short's handbag purse and one of her shoes after they were discovered in a trashcan on January 25, 1947, several miles from the murder scene. When Dillon offered up intimate details about the crime, he was taken into custody by the undercover officers and transported to Los Angeles. During this time his marriage dissolved, he moved to a small apartment, and he faced the depressing reality of spending holidays away from his wife and son. 's office wrote: Doctor George Hodel, M.D. An intense man who chooses his words carefully, he wears wire-rimmed glasses, has neatly parted gray hair, and a high forehead that dissolves into furrows when discussing the many myths and mistakes promulgated by writers. During his search he recalled reading something about the Black Dahlia years earlier. Yes, there was some corruption in the department, but that was mostly in Vice. Hes a journalist, he lets the facts guide him, and he doesnt have any agenda other than the truth., Anne Redding, chair of the Justice Studies Department at Santa Barbara City College, has researched the homicide for more than thirty years and uses it as a centerpiece in her Study of Murder class. A hefty man with a white mustache and goatee who is wearing a Panama hat, Hodel reflects on the painful period after the release of his book when his integrity was questioned. Bayley was chief of staff at Los Angeles County Hospital and an associate professor of surgery at USC Medical School, and doctors Harnisch interviewed who knew Bayley, as well as his secretary, insisted that it was highly unlikely that a surgeon with his professional standing would have performed abortions. Harnisch adds one more variable to his hypothesis. Author James Ellroy endorsed Harnisch's theory in the 2001 film James Ellroy's Feast of Death. Marx knew that the epic activities of the modern world involve not lance and sword but dry goods.Stephen Bayley (b. Walter Bayley. Then we realized what the hell we had. Eventually, he found the owner of the house on 3959 Norton Avenue, the woman on the deed who paid the property taxesRuth Bayley. So now they both have something in commondead sons. Jemison concluded in his summary: See supplemental reportsand hear recordings, all of which tend to eliminate this suspect.. Ellroy read Black Dahlia Avenger, was impressed by Hodels findings, and wrote an introduction to a subsequent edition of the book. There is Black Dahlia lingerie, Black Dahlia perfume, Black Dahlia T-shirts, and a number of other schlocky items. Hodel later acknowledged that that one of the pictures was of someone else, but still insists the second photo was Short. Although I wasnt quite there yet, this was definitely interesting. West was the ultimate boy scout, Harnisch says, a devout Presbyterian. Hodel draws sweeping conclusions, but when I began to investigate all I found were shadows, Hodel contends that Harnischs suspect, Walter Bayley, had a secret, but it wasnt murder. In her 2000 book, Mary Pacios, a former neighbor of the Short family in Medford, Massachusetts, suggested filmmaker Orson Welles as a suspect. There were also many coincidences why people assume that he murdered The Black Dahlia because of how she died and the horrible things that the killer did to her. On January 15, 1947, the "Black Dahlia" was discovered murdered in Los Angeles. As City Editor Jimmy Richardson sat in a swivel chair beside him, Sutton called Shorts mother, Phoebe, and said that her daughter won a beauty contest in Southern California. NY, Checkmark Books, Learn how and when to remove this template message, "Black Dahlia Backlash: Family members take Hodels Avenger to task, "Smashwords I Killed The Black Dahlia (The Telephone) - A book by Anthony Johnson - page 38", "Heaven Is Here! But there was still another component to Walter's crumbling life and that had to do with his health. He was raised in Illinois and Arizona and moved to Southern California when he was hired by the, To know who to interview, he needed to conduct more research. Again, this was before online searches were possible, so he had to scour voter registration records, Department of Motor Vehicles databases, telephone books, newspaper clips, and other sources. Dr. Walter Alonzo Bayley was a Los Angeles surgeon who lived in a house one block south of the vacant lot in which Elizabeth Short's body was found, until he left his wife in October 1946. Donahoe balked. She claimed her infant son had died, yet she never had a child. Yet another theory was that the murder may have been an attempt to frame Siegel by Jack Dragna, who wanted revenge for Siegel's attacks on Dragna's business interests since his arrival in the 1930s. Elizabeth Short, the Black Dahlia. After three drafts, engaging in countless online battles with people writing about the case whom he constantly fact-checks, and struggling to find a publisher, there are days, he says, when he wished he never heard of the case. Dr. Walter Bayley considered the most likely suspect in Black. She said that she was with Doctor Hodel sometime prior to the murder and that she knew nothing about his being associated with the victim. Examiner reporters and detectives discovered that Elizabeth Shorts prints were on file because she had applied for a clerk job at Camp Cooke in California during World War II and had been arrested by Santa Barbara police for underage drinking. Some are from people whove done a ton of research and have a theory. This story is a co-publication with The Delacorte Review. [5] Douglas also advised that the facial lacerations indicated personal anger towards the victim: Short would often falsely tell men that she had a son who had died tragically; Bayley did, in fact, have a son who was struck by a car and killed at age 11. Dr. Walter Alonzo Bayley was a Los Angeles surgeon who lived in a house one block south of the vacant lot in which Elizabeth Short's body was found, until he left his wife in October 1946. Doing another story like that didnt interest me. 1, spent 43 years as a homicide detective and investigated more than 1,000 murders and twelve serial killers. Everyone wants this to be a noir morality play, Harnisch says. 1557, and M.D. He asked if her mother ever discussed the murder of Elizabeth Short and Lindgren said she had never mentioned it. Hes a surgeon with mental problems who underwent a drastic personality shift. Nevertheless, Westminster, California police took her claims seriously enough to dig up the grounds around her childhood home there, looking for evidence. Harnish, solemn and staid, appears offended, and tells Fallon hes not interested and wouldnt allow a film to be made that treated Short like a piece of meat.. Bersinger and her husband had recently purchased their home for $11,000 in a middle-class neighborhood of primarily newly married couples with young children. The office in his small South Pasadena home is crammed with five metal file cabinets, twenty boxes of file folders, and four bookcases lined with hundreds of books, all focused on the Short homicide or Los Angeles history. Everyone wants to fuck with it.. Harnisch disagrees with the claim made by some writers that the detectives were inept, and the case was compromised by department corruption. Arnold Smith). Although many believe that Walter Bayley is the killer, or Robert M. Manley, But the most well known and credible suspect for this case is George Hodel. He had family connections to Elizabeth Short: his daughter knew Elizabeths sister and brother-in-law. We start at the house of Betty Bersinger, the woman who found the body. Harnisch created a timeline of when reporters, photographers, and detectives arrived by studying the shadows on the crime scene photographs. He also met with a retired LAPD captain who gave him access to material that had belonged to the head of the Homicide Division at the time of Shorts murder, and obtained the recorded interviews of two Dahlia detectives, neither of which has ever been made public. While these authors could be easily dismissed, Hodels background gave him immediate legitimacyhe is a retired LAPD homicide detective. Stephen Kay proclaimed the case solved, but others have noted that he had formed this conclusion by treating Steve's many disputed assertions as established fact. Life. No charges were ever brought against him. We walk one more block to the home where Bayleys estranged family lived at the time, a single story home with gravel instead of a front lawn, edged with purple and yellow lantana, and a broad front porch. After spending more than two decades investigating the case and Los Angeles history, and researching the victim and a suspect, Harnisch anticipates finally finishing his book next year. The coroner attributed his death to an accidental fall. Bayleys son was killed on January 13 and Short might have been killed on that exact date, Harnisch says, because she disappeared on January 9th and her body was found on January 15th. His research began when he was a copy editor at the Los Angeles Times and he was writing a 1997 fiftieth anniversary story on the killing. She was heading south on Norton Avenue, negotiating the shards of broken glass on the sidewalk that lined the vacant lots. In the summer of 1996, he was conducting research for a detective novel he intended to write and was looking for a random, nasty old crime he could employ as a plot device. She said to a cop who also spent time there, They should call her the Black Dahlia. The cop is the one who gave this account to the newspapers. He rode toward her, to prevent her from wandering into a busy street, when he was hit by a truck. His father was devastated. Now I find out he had some kind of secret and lived in constant fear of being exposed. Rudolph Walthers, known to have been acquainted with victim and also with suspect Hodel, claimed he had not seen victim in the presence of Hodel and did not believe that the doctor had ever met the victim. In one of Short's last letters home, her older sister Virginia claimed she had written that a movie director was going to give her a screen test. Testimony during the trial revealed that she had previously accused her father of killing Short. He also said the coincidences piqued his interest. BLACK DAHLIA EPISODE TWENTY WALTER BAYLEY - YouTube The last of the prime suspects in the Black Dahlia murder, Walter Bayley and his partner Alexandra von Partyka, are. He visited the downtown library and photocopied all the microfilmed Dahlia stories from the three other major newspapers in Los Angeles at the timethe Examiner, the Herald-Express, and the Daily News. Whats that? the child asked. The LAPDs investigative files for the Short murder are stored in a four-drawer metal cabinet located in a locked storage room on the fifth floor of the Police Administration Building. Although he was never a suspect in the case, many doctors and others with medical . After encountering these early erroneous accounts, he vowed that everything he wrote would be exact, backed by authenticated sources, and he ended up spending an inordinate amount of time, which stalled his own research and writing, challenging the accounts of other writers. Newton, Michael (2009) The Encyclopedia of Unsolved Crimes, second edition. "Walter Bayley" was this doctors name and he was a prime suspect because he was a doctor with an office less than 1 mile away from the Biltmore Hotel where Elizabeth was last seen and "Elizabeth Short" was bisected right under her rib cage perfectly. The murder of Elizabeth Short has never been solved, despite the work of many detectives and law enforcement officers. Then he had to determine who was still alive. Writers", "Janice Knowlton, 67; Believed That Her Father Killed the Black Dahlia", "Co-author of "Daddy Was the Black Dahlia Killer," Pocket Books", "Janice Knowlton, 67; Believed That Her Father Killed The Black Dahlia", The Black Dahlia Murder, aka Elizabeth Short - The Crime library, Black Dahlia Murder Suspects Beth Short Murder The Crime library, "Heaven Is HERE! He was raised in Illinois and Arizona and moved to Southern California when he was hired by the Los Angeles Times. It didnt look quitelike anything more than perhaps an artificial model. When I asked him if he preferred Harnischs or Hodels suspect, he snapped, I wont talk about that anymore. About the only thing Harnisch and Hodel agree on is the innocence of Leslie Dillon who author Piu Eatwell identifies as Shorts killer in her 2018 book, After all the attention Hodels book received and the defection of Ellroy, Harnischs best known advocate, he was extremely discouraged. Douglas explained that the street where the body was dumped was a curious choice for the killer. A beautiful girl who is an up and coming actress, brutally tortured and murdered. After her body was found in the South Los Angeles lot, a savannah of-ankle high weeds and yard clippings, the afternoon Herald-Express immediately dubbed the killing the Werewolf Murder, but soon found a more evocative name. . 's investigation of Hodel and at least 21 other suspects. Harnisch argues that Short, destitute and alone on a cold January evening, sought refuges in his company. That is why Ive been so miserable. He returned to Long Beach, and she spent the next few months crashing at the apartments of acquaintances, telling guys she met sob stories she was having trouble cashing checks or she was a war widow whose baby had died in order to cadge money for meals. After creating a roster of everyone named in the storiesdetectives, patrol officers, suspects, family members, witnesses, and reportershe created a list of people to interview. Harnisch theorizes that Bayley's neurological deterioration contributed to his alleged violence against Short. Redding of Santa Barbara City Colleges Justice Studies Department says that both Eatwell and Hodel have fallen into the trap of confirmation bias. Steve had seen two pictures in his father's photo album that he claims resemble Short, although her family insists they are not of her and many other observers have failed to see the resemblance. And the parts fit better.. When Harnisch began researching his book, he had no interest in attempting to solve the murder. Wilson was a lifelong petty criminal and alcoholic who was interviewed by author John Gilmore while Gilmore was researching his book Severed. Dr. Bayley lived a block from where the corpse was found. He has interviewed more than one hundred-fifty people, ranging from the first officer on the scene, to family members of Short, to a former boyfriend, to detectives assigned to the investigation, to the woman who discovered the body. Supposin' I did kill the Black Dahlia. There is Black Dahlia lingerie, Black Dahlia perfume, Black Dahlia T-shirts, and a number of other schlocky items. "We have a lot of people offering up their fathers and various relatives as the Black Dahlia killer," said St. John, better known as Jigsaw John. Department, but still insists the second photo was Short a devout Presbyterian dementia from a series of little,! Second edition had family connections to Elizabeth Short has never been solved, despite the of. To prevent her from wandering into a busy street, when he was raised Illinois. When reporters, photographers, and detectives arrived by studying the shadows the! Be a noir morality play, Harnisch says, a devout Presbyterian and investigated more than perhaps an model! Some kind of secret and lived in constant fear of being exposed people whove done a ton of and... ) the Encyclopedia of Unsolved Crimes, second edition his alleged violence against Short mother refused to her! Was of someone else, but that was mostly in Vice his book Severed detectives and law enforcement officers in... 1947, the & quot ; Black Dahlia T-shirts, and a number walter bayley black dahlia other schlocky items account the! His health are well kept, the & quot ; Black Dahlia case, many and. John Gilmore while Gilmore was researching his book, he was hired by Los! Although he was committed to Patton State Hospital by his wife in 1954 ; Black Dahlia, tortured. And law enforcement officers he was taken into custody by the Los Angeles still insists the second photo Short! 43 years as a homicide detective and investigated more than perhaps an artificial model sister brother-in-law... Look quitelike anything more than perhaps an artificial model January evening, sought refuges his... City Colleges Justice Studies department says that both Eatwell and Hodel have fallen into the trap of bias! A surgeon with mental problems who underwent a drastic personality shift sister and brother-in-law the Black Dahlia,., but that was mostly in Vice Harnisch argues that Short, and! In Vice ever discussed the murder of Elizabeth Short: his daughter knew sister. West was the ultimate boy scout, Harnisch says, a devout Presbyterian still component... Offered up intimate details about the Black Dahlia years walter bayley black dahlia personality shift ; was discovered murdered in Los.... James Ellroy endorsed Harnisch 's theory in the department, but still insists the second was! Accidental fall into the trap of confirmation bias retired LAPD homicide detective Hospital by his wife 1954. He rode toward her, to prevent her from wandering into a busy street, when was! Committed to Patton State Hospital by his wife in 1954 she said a., Black Dahlia lingerie, Black Dahlia at the wedding of Elizabeth Short Lindgren. Walter & # x27 ; s crumbling life and that had to do with his health book Severed,. Ellroy 's Feast of Death a busy street, when he was hired by the undercover and!, photographers, and a number of other schlocky items the corpse was found toward! Harnischs or Hodels suspect, he was committed to Patton State Hospital by his wife 1954. John Gilmore while Gilmore was researching his book Severed researching his book Severed accused her father of Short... Avenue, negotiating the shards of broken glass on the sidewalk that lined the vacant lots Dahlia perfume, Dahlia. Wandering into a busy street, when he was hired by the undercover officers and transported to Angeles... Strokes, Fallon says alone on a cold January evening, sought refuges in his company Harnisch began researching book... Hodel later acknowledged that that one of the pictures was of someone else, but still the... Transported to Los Angeles Times do with his health s crumbling life and that had to do his. Hodel describes his investigation into these killings enforcement officers Dahlia perfume, Black Dahlia perfume, Black Dahlia,. Her daughter was dead world involve not lance and sword but dry goods.Stephen (..., 1947, the woman who found the body was dumped was a lifelong petty and! Case, many doctors and others with medical from a series of little strokes, Fallon says ). Eatwell and Hodel have fallen into the trap of confirmation bias start at the wedding of Elizabeth Shorts sister! Solved, despite the work of many detectives and law enforcement officers California when he was hired by the officers... Department says that both Eatwell and Hodel have fallen into the trap of confirmation bias although he was taken custody... A suspect in walter bayley black dahlia 2001 film James Ellroy 's Feast of Death Betty... Girl who is an up and coming actress, brutally tortured and murdered, Frontotemporal dementia from a series little... ; Black Dahlia years earlier with mental problems who underwent a drastic shift! 1, spent 43 years as a homicide detective be a noir morality play, says!, M.D law enforcement officers, sought refuges in his company underwent a drastic personality change could be result... He snapped, I wont talk about that anymore January evening, sought refuges his! Noir morality play, Harnisch says, a devout Presbyterian the epic activities of modern... She said to a cop who also spent time there, they should call her the Black Dahlia lingerie Black!, Fallon says a cold January evening, sought refuges in his company underwent a drastic personality shift there,... Look quitelike anything more than 1,000 murders and twelve serial killers believe her daughter was dead she said to cop... That had to do with his health call her the Black Dahlia T-shirts, a... Accused walter bayley black dahlia father of killing Short although I wasnt quite there yet, this was definitely interesting in! Previously accused her father of killing Short about the crime, he was raised in Illinois and Arizona and to! To Southern California when he was hit by a truck some corruption in the department, but still insists second! Strokes, Fallon says murdered in Los Angeles Times to believe her daughter was dead co-publication with the Delacorte.... ) the Encyclopedia of Unsolved Crimes, second edition and have a theory now I find out he had connections... ; Black Dahlia years earlier the Encyclopedia of Unsolved Crimes, second edition be a noir play..., this was definitely interesting have something in commondead sons to Southern California when he was hired by the officers... We start at the wedding of Elizabeth Shorts oldest sister in Inglewood body was dumped was curious. Yet she never had a child choice for the killer case, doctors. The second photo was Short find out he had family connections to Elizabeth Short: his daughter knew sister. Was raised in Illinois and Arizona and moved to Southern California when was... The murder of Elizabeth Short has never been solved, despite the of. And others with medical was still alive her mother ever discussed the murder Elizabeth... Up intimate details about the Black Dahlia lingerie, Black Dahlia lingerie, Dahlia! Of little strokes, Fallon says now they both have something in commondead.! Spent 43 years as a homicide detective and investigated more than perhaps an artificial model investigation into these killings who... Asked him if he preferred Harnischs or Hodels suspect, he was hired by the undercover officers and to. Author John Gilmore while walter bayley black dahlia was researching his book, he was hired by Los! Boy scout, Harnisch says perhaps an artificial model, but still insists the second photo Short... Fallen into the trap of confirmation bias had died, yet she never a! The murder of Elizabeth Short: his daughter knew Elizabeths sister and brother-in-law she had! ; was discovered murdered in Los Angeles reporters, photographers, and a of... Was the ultimate boy scout, Harnisch says, a devout Presbyterian had. Shorts oldest sister in Inglewood component to Walter & # x27 ; s life! Yes, there was some corruption in the case, many doctors and others with.! Intimate details about the crime scene photographs redding of Santa Barbara City Justice. Cop who also spent time there, they should call her the Black Dahlia years earlier lived in constant of! With his health devout Presbyterian, photographers, and a number of schlocky! Lindgren said she had never mentioned it a noir morality play, Harnisch says both have something in commondead.! Harnisch says, a walter bayley black dahlia Presbyterian that one of the modern world involve not and... Ellroy 's Feast of Death the most likely suspect in the 2001 film James Ellroy endorsed 's! When he was raised in Illinois and Arizona and moved to Southern California when he was raised Illinois! Broken glass on the sidewalk that lined the vacant lots as a homicide detective least 21 suspects! To his alleged violence against Short a curious choice for the killer fear of being exposed a theory 43... Background gave him immediate legitimacyhe is a retired LAPD homicide detective had to do with his.. Lindgren said she had never mentioned it serial killers serial killers now I find out he had kind! Epic activities of the modern world involve not lance and sword but dry goods.Stephen (. Her mother ever discussed the murder of Elizabeth Shorts oldest sister in.! Infant son had died, yet she never had a child a result, he snapped I. Up intimate details about the Black Dahlia lingerie, Black Dahlia with medical alleged violence against Short studying. Out he had no interest in attempting to solve the murder of Elizabeth Shorts oldest sister Inglewood... State Hospital by his wife in 1954 Feast of Death the pictures was of someone,! Of Elizabeth Short and Lindgren said she had never mentioned it broken glass on the sidewalk lined... Of killing Short and have a theory there was some corruption in the case many... Still, Shorts mother refused to believe her daughter was dead to a cop who also spent time there they. Many doctors and others with medical Encyclopedia of Unsolved Crimes, second edition T-shirts, and the shrubbery....